13 November 2026 · Season 7, episode 3 · 57 min

JusticeFred Myers

on mentoring, the broken civil justice system, and technology, five years later

No.100
On YouTube ↗

Transcript

8,870 words · about 39 min to read

Recorded 11 November 2026. Machine transcript; names checked by AI against the episode notes.

Mark the passages that stay with you: press the number beside a paragraph. Marks are anonymous, and the most-marked passages help choose what goes into the book.

To hear a passage, press ▸ under its number; it plays just that paragraph.

See a misspelled name or a wrong word? Select it and press Report an error, or email the correction. The transcript is machine-made; corrections are welcome.

Pulat Yunusov

Hello everyone, welcome to another episode of the Yunusov Question. This is a very special episode, not only because it's episode number 100, but also because it's a special judicial episode and a second visit of this particular guest, very special guest. His name is Justice Fred Myers of the Ontario Court of Appeal. Hello, Justice Myers.

Justice Fred Myers

Good afternoon, Pulat.

Pulat Yunusov

It's very good to have you. And this is part 2 of our conversation. To refresh your memory, part 1 happened almost 5 years ago in December 2021. And if you don't mind, I'm going to have flashbacks to part 1, and we will have a sort of a retrospective, and then we will also talk about the present and the future. There's no present or future without the past. Excellent. Okay, so first of all, a few things changed since December 2021. I wear glasses now. You became a judge of the Court of Appeal. So to each his own. So tell me about your first— first of all, congratulations on becoming a judge of the Court of Appeal.

I think a lot of people were very, very excited and happy to hear that announcement. Can you please share your first impressions of this job, how they received you over there at the Court of Appeal? What happened? What's going on? When it started?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, I'm brand, brand new, so there's really only so much I can say. I've sat one week of motions and a couple of panel days. I've got my first panels coming up in the next two weeks. Next week is civil, and the week after is criminal. But so far, I couldn't be happier with the— I'm more charged for this new adventure. I mean, the Chief Justice and the Associate Chief Justice have been extremely welcoming and accessible, and My new colleagues have all been very generous with offering assistance and welcoming me and the two other judges that I was appointed with. I can tell you the most noticeable issue has been the amount of support available and the culture of support that exists here.

I don't have to do everything myself anymore. There are people around to provide administrative and procedural and substantive help. And if I want to chat, there are people who are interested in chatting. It's— I can really tell this is a place that's committed to excellence, and they provide the judges with the tools to try to provide the service to the public. It's uplifting after years of solitude and some despair.

Pulat Yunusov

That's great to hear. And we'll talk about solitude on the Superior Court versus being on a panel at the Court of Appeal. But thank you for mentioning your colleagues. I interviewed a few of them on the show, so I interviewed the Associate Chief, Justice Michal Fairburn. And one thing I know I'm not going to ask you about is how to get elevated from a trial court to the Court of Appeal, because she spoke to that topic. I urge everyone to go watch and listen and read that interview. I also interviewed Justice Sossin, and you mentioned the support and the colleagues, and he also talked about something similar. He— his surprise on appointment was intense collegiality.

So I guess this hasn't changed at the Court of Appeal. Very nice to hear.

Justice Fred Myers

That's all that I've seen so far.

Pulat Yunusov

So, you know, this is a very different court, and I guess it has somewhat different standards from the Superior Court. You mentioned the solitude. You, I believe, mostly heard cases alone in the Superior Court. Now, unless it's a motion, you sit on a panel. When you talked to me last time, 5 years ago, you said that, you know, you are not the person with a standard historic, totally in the box, adjective-free neutrality, right? So you have a character. I love people with character. But when you are solo, when you're alone, I mean, having character, I guess, is easier. Now you're not alone anymore. You're on panel. So how does it work on panels? And how does it work when you have to work out a joint opinion?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, I don't know so much about the Court of Appeal yet, but I did sit on the divisional court for 2 years after the time you and I spoke last. And I can tell you, I mean, you obviously have to make some choices and sometimes compromise a little if you want to get your colleagues to sign on. But I learned a long time ago, coming from big firms, that a lot of documents are negotiated by committee. And my rule is, if somebody wants a change, I make it unless it's really important. And if it's really important, I don't. And, you know, live with that. I can tell you that in 2 years at the divisional court, and there was One colleague in particular who I had a very different approach towards cases than she did, and I respected her a lot though, although we don't see eye to eye politically, neither of us ever dissented.

We were always able to find common ground, a paragraph here, a sentence there, move this one, move that one. There were two dissents from me, but I carried the majority in both cases, so I'm okay with that. But I plan on, you know, learning from my colleagues how things are, what the expectations are here, how this place works. But I don't plan on losing my voice. I, you know, I like talking about best practices and how decisions affect lawyers and the practice in the real world. And there's, I think there's, I gotta be more hesitant about obiter here. Obiter in a high court, a superior court decision, I'm one of 350 judges. Spouting off, but when it comes to the Court of Appeal, you're, you're binding everybody.

So I'll be circumspect where appropriate. But I think when, when I need to say something, I'm going to say it.

Pulat Yunusov

It's interesting. You spoke about one limitation, which is really sort of the responsibility of power, of additional power, where you have to pay attention to what you say because of the audience and how the audience will treat your words differently than when you're on the Superior Court. But do you think there are also extensions to your power? Do you think you will have more authority to speak with your personal voice now because it's a higher court? Do you— what do you— what do you think about this?

Justice Fred Myers

I hope so. I, I've been told recently that only 2% of our cases go to the Supreme Court of Canada. So in the almost unanimous case circumstances, our decisions are the last word and the decisions are binding. So I think, I think I'll have a lot more time now to deal with law rather than just moving the freight. And I hope to be able to make a meaningful contribution. I'm 67 already, so I only have 8 years left maximum. But Justice Zarnett came at the exact same age. He's recently retired, and I hope to be able to make, you know, half the contribution he made. I'd be very I'd be very satisfied.

Pulat Yunusov

You know, in our last interview, again, 5 years ago, I keep going back to it, you said that you're only on the Superior Court. I'm paraphrasing, paraphrasing. You're not on the Court of Appeals, so you don't make law. And I inferred from that that in your view, the Court of Appeals makes law. Do you think your view has changed since then, or do you think it's the same? And how do you approach your new gig with this view, with the view that you are now one of the people who make the law?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, with humility, which people don't expect to hear from me, but I think it's vital. I think it's a different role. I don't think we make new law every single day. I think we have a role. A lot of what we do is clarifying, and there is error correction, of course, which occupies a lot of time. If you look at the Court of Appeal website, you'll see that most decisions are very short endorsements that are just error corrections. The amount of really big significant decisions is much, much less, but absolutely it's making law, or, you know, putting— evolving law as the common law does on a case-by-case basis and adding nuances where appropriate. So it's a huge responsibility.

I think of the recent decision in the bike lanes case where the Court of Appeal reminded all of us to stay in our lanes. Policy is the role of the legislature, and we're dealing with the common law and 500 years of tradition, evolving cases as they're presented to us.

Pulat Yunusov

I want to revisit 3 big topics that we covered in your previous interview in 2021. They are lawyers' competence, number 1, The civil justice system, number 2, and technology, number 3. I mean, technology was really important by the end of 2021 because of this huge transition to the digital court system due to the pandemic. The last time we spoke with you, they still counted the COVID cases and things like that. So I want to start with lawyers' competence. It's been 5 years. What's the status quo? What's, what's the update on this situation? I mean, you've had so much input since our last meeting in the last 5 years. You've had so much data. What's, what's the situation today?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, The mentoring problem that I think I talked about last time is much exacerbated, unfortunately, and it's a couple of things. The lawyers who were called to the bar during the pandemic and since, I don't know how many of them have even been to court on their own yet, but also the staying home and being a remote a practitioner is a real problem for getting mentoring and learning those things that you need to learn by experience. I really encourage— I know it's convenient to stay home. I like staying home to do my work, but if you're a young lawyer looking to learn, you've got to be in an office where you can chat with the person next door to you informally, because you're not going to arrange a Zoom call to talk about a silly little question that dawns on you, and You're not going to hear people walking around the halls talking about their cases or their war stories from court.

I love to talk about my colleagues who used to always do a victory lap around the office when they came home after a win. There's so much to be learned in the office, just watching people dealing with clients and with support staff. I really worry about the development of skills also because of are online hearings. There's no opportunities now to go to court and sit there all day when you're number 20 on a list and you see the 19 cases before you and learn what works and what doesn't work. Now you get to bill while you're sitting in the waiting room, and then you come and you go. And I think that's a huge problem, that young litigators aren't seeing the volume of litigation.

And I really encourage everybody who thinks they want to be a litigator to take charge of their own skill development if their firm isn't, and become duty counsel, do pro bono counsel, like volunteer pro bono a night a week or something. There used to be— I don't know if you still can do per diem prosecution work, perhaps. There's all kinds of ways to develop litigation skills, and it's sorely, sorely needed.

Pulat Yunusov

You said, you mentioned the volume of litigation work, but, and that young lawyers are not getting that volume. But we're getting, we're getting a volume of young lawyers though. And, you know, more, they're planning on opening more law schools. So I just saw a tweet, I think, somewhere. I'm sorry, I'm not giving credit because I don't remember who it was who said, and I think it was a pseudonymous account. So they are planning to open two more law schools in Ontario. So now our 1,000-lawyer firm received, you know, our large firm received 1,000 student applications for 12 positions. So now we will receive 1,500 applications for 12 positions. What's going to change, right? So what do you think about the role of law schools and do we need more law schools in this country or in this province?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, you know, there are probably some places where a judge ought not to wade too deeply into. We all know the problem of how are people going to make a living, but that's not really— I don't know the economics of the universities and where the Law Society sits compared to where the law schools and the law firms. It baffles me a little bit, but I don't know. I think I better not weigh in with a political view.

Pulat Yunusov

Yeah, it's hard to say because it's still the supply and demand. And not only supply demand because of the living or making money, it's also, as you said, it's the scarce supply of mentoring spots.

Justice Fred Myers

And I suspect that within some firms, the role of mentoring must be somewhat less valued now because I'm just, from what I'm hearing, there's just less and less mentoring opportunities. And I think people are busy in trying to build their hours or build their work and not really necessarily concentrate on developing their associates. And we can talk later when we talk about IT, the development of associates, or not IT, AI, excuse me, development of associates is an issue of real concern. With AI.

Pulat Yunusov

I'm not going to ask you about the Law Society. I think you made it clear that you don't want to talk about it, but you spoke about the Law Society the last time we met. But let's leave it be this time. I don't think a lot has changed, but we'll see.

Justice Fred Myers

Well, Justice Dunphy is doing my work for me.

Pulat Yunusov

Okay, maybe I should interview him next. Please connect us. You know, your biggest complaint in 2021 was counsel who come to court unprepared. You didn't have a lot of time on the panel or in motions court at the Court of Appeal yet, but your first impression, the quality of counsel that appear before you, your first impression?

Justice Fred Myers

First impression is that criminal appellate bar is specialized and seem to really know the ropes. In civil, it's interesting that people tend to take their own appeals, and I wonder how good a strategy that is because you're so fixed on your case and what you lost below, as opposed to somebody thinking about how am I going to pitch this to 3 new judges to maximize my chances of success. And new, old counsel, continuing counsel won't point out errors in their own strategic thinking, perhaps, that a fresh counsel could. So I think the civil bar could think about using more appellate lawyers and developing more appellate lawyers because it's different. It's a different skill set.

Pulat Yunusov

I agree with you. I guess not everyone can afford to hire Mark Gelowitz or Andrew Bernstein. Who, by the way, was a guest of the show in the past. I guess it comes down to scarcity again when lower-level counsel proceeds to the next level. It's like the next level in the video game, but it really isn't. Yeah, I agree with you. So technology is the next topic that was really important for you back in the day, 5 years ago, understandably so. You know what, I think— let me ask you, do you think everything changed in the 5 years when it comes to technology? And do you, do you, do you, do you think you, you could have any idea about what it would be like today?

Justice Fred Myers

Not everything has changed. The Court of Appeal doesn't have Case Center yet, for example, although, although it may soon, hopefully. But the technology has changed certainly for the better than when we started into the pandemic and there was literally nothing. It's not necessarily 100% optimal today, but it's much, much better, and the bar has gotten used to it. And the new digital transformation project that is slowly being implemented has done some really good things. Certainly, I can tell you, I can access now everything filed in the court. Believe it or not, for my 12 years prior, I couldn't access your pleadings, for example, if I was hearing your case. I could only see what was in the motion record, but now we can access everything, which is great.

The judgment drafting parts of the C-Track process don't do much for us. It hasn't changed much at all the complexities that the computer has added to drafting your judgments. And in fact, it's— the computer's made drafting judgments harder than the simple handwritten endorsement that was quite, quite easy to do. And so it's taken a lot longer to— not so much because of technology, particular technology, just as soon as you start typing, you feel the need to say more, to give more background. So it's hard to do a short endorsement when you're typing, and then you're typing yourself, which is whole other problem. But the one thing I'd really love to see— I don't know how the Bar has responded to the distribution of decisions on the system, but in the United States, if you want to serve and file a document, you can just upload it to PACER, their court system, press a button, it tells everybody, document's filed, you're served.

And so that— I don't know if that's something in the future for C-Track. I think it probably has the capability to do that. That would be a wonderful thing to see, for example. Yeah,

Pulat Yunusov

that's, that's really cutting edge. I think it was like 2002 technology or something, but we're still craving it. Well, of course, the elephant in the room is AI, and we will talk about it separately. You, of all judges, are famous for your treatment of AI in law practice. And I want to have a separate discussion about it. But continuing on technology other than AI, when we spoke 5 years ago, you said hybrid hearings will come in almost every case. And the profession at the time was resisting CaseLines, as Case Center was known back then. You said the paper is done. Experts will testify remotely. Now, today the message from the courts is come to the courthouse.

Do you think this is the message, or do you think this message is correct? What do you think about it?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, I think we are learning to be efficient and what works best for what. I think there's a lot of resistance to going back to the courthouse, for example, for case conferences or short motions. I can tell you that family in Toronto is all in person now. And notwithstanding some people barking about that in public, they missed the whole point, which is when everything went remote, lawyers weren't standing out in the hall together and cases stopped settling because lawyers are working while they're in the waiting room. They're not talking to each other. And so case conferences, it used to be in family, you do a case conference, you say, okay, here are 3 issues, you know, support and equalization degree of access or whatever, and go out in the hall and work on one of them.

Let's see if we can get one resolved today. And you'd send the lawyers out, they'd go work on it, and then you do your next case conference while they're out in the hall. And that didn't happen. That doesn't happen remotely. So bringing everybody in is, is an effort to get lawyers talking again, especially with emails now so firmly taken over that nobody even wants to pick up a phone. You bring people in. I understand that out of town, that a lot of courts are going in person, and I don't quite understand. You'll have to talk to somebody who understands it better, because I thought lawyers traveling town to town, and clients in particular traveling town to town, would love remote.

So I'm not sure how that works or why, but I do know, well, you know, criminal is largely in person, as it should be, but not but not JPTs, for example. We're, we're civil is in person certainly for trials but you do get remote hybrid witnesses. I don't think it's a big deal now to mention hybrid. Can your honour, can this witness be testify remotely? Of course. So there's a lot of, there's a lot of savings through remote still, even within person. But I think we're finding the right balance.

Pulat Yunusov

Do you think that powers that be just don't understand the young people and the new generation? I mean, they don't even know— the young people don't even know how to answer phone calls anymore. I mean, they get spooked if they get a phone call. I mean, has to be a scam or something. And they don't really— I don't think they spend a lot of time in person, not as much as I did when I was young. And I wonder if the new generation just solves problems differently now. They don't need to be— to see each other, to be close to each other, to look at each other's faces, look each other in the eyes anymore.

Do you think that this is an unstoppable trend and it's still going to go remote fully at some point, especially with the rise of AI, which we will talk about separately?

Justice Fred Myers

I'm not positive. I know if you put young people who are too young together in the same room, they'll just text each other. But, but I'm not sure. I mean, the question is, are they settling cases? Are they, are they achieving their results? What scares me most about email communication between lawyers is you copy your client, and so therefore there's tone in the email. You know, when you get the lawyers in person, in private, they can be a little more straightforward with each other and say, look, I can get my client here, can you get your client there, kind of thing. But I think that's also, it's part and parcel with mentoring, Pulat, because I think some unmentored people still think it's like TV.

I think they think they have to go the nth degree on every point, yield no quarter, don't give an adjournment. You know, the number of times I've written that counsel don't need instructions to grant an adjournment, and there but for the grace of God go I, when your colleague phones you up and says, look, I need an adjournment, I'm sorry. It's, you know, my kids tell me I'm the quintessential boomer, so I'm not in the right, I'm not the right person to be talking about what they're going to be able to do. But I do think it's important that we get the message out there that whatever it is, however it is they're going to do it, they have to communicate with their colleagues in a meaningful and cooperative way to get things done.

Pulat Yunusov

Well, I wonder if appeals are slightly different. Justice Fairburn, Associate Chief Fairburn, in her interview said that appellate work is uniquely conducive to online hearings. Well, that was a few years ago also, so I don't know, maybe the rules of the game have changed slightly. Justice Stratas of Federal Court of Appeal said that Oral, he compared litigation to a hockey game, and he said of 60 minutes of 3 periods, oral argument is just the last 8 minutes. That's his opinion, right? So, and maybe again, he's on an appellate court. He is on an appellate court. And this is their view. Do you think that appeals are different when it comes to in-person interactions? Again, the settlement considerations are not as important and so on and so forth.

Justice Fred Myers

I don't think there's much difference between the logistics. Obviously the substance is different, but the logistics of an appeal and a motion are very similar. So particularly for a short appeal, I'm perfectly happy with online. I'd be happy with online for a longer appeal, but I know a lot of people prefer to be close and have the opportunity. It's good to have your colleagues together in one place because, you know, we jump out into a a little conference room in between sittings and before. I guess you can do that in a breakout room online, I don't know. But I, I don't, I don't have a strong feel. I agree with the Associate Chief. I don't think there's anything precluding effective remote, remote arguing appeals.

But I, I— someone doesn't like it because we're in person, which is, which is also fine.

Pulat Yunusov

Well, I think we should talk about the civil justice system now. This was one of the three big topics 5 years ago. I, I think it's still a huge topic. You probably consider yourself more of a civil judge rather than a criminal judge. I don't know if you've ever heard criminal cases, by the way. Did you?

Justice Fred Myers

I have, briefly.

Pulat Yunusov

Okay, so when we talked about the civil justice system in 2021, you said that the system is acknowledged to be broken at the highest levels.

Justice Fred Myers

Chief Justice Morawetz said those words at the opening of a court a couple of years ago.

Pulat Yunusov

And I guess it's still broken.

Justice Fred Myers

10 years after he admonished me for saying them.

Pulat Yunusov

But it's still broken, right? I mean, no one can say in good faith today that it's unbroken now. We unbroken finally, right? And what you also said is that nobody really is that interested in fixing it. We put Band-Aids on every— we put Band-Aids on every now and again. And then we talked about summary judgment motions. And back then you said that almost 90% of summary judgments are upheld, yet the Court of Appeals message in the big cases is be very careful. So what do you think about summary judgment motions today? I mean, the way that summary judgment motions have evolved is nothing short of a soap opera in Ontario over the last 15 years that I practiced law.

And where do you think they're headed especially now with the rise of technology?

Justice Fred Myers

I'm afraid that Hryniak was a, an experiment that came and went. It's, it had such potential to, even with a summary judgment failed, you could then have case management to a appointed trial, a quicker— but there was no resource ability within the court to do that. The judges weren't able, if you're especially out of Toronto where you circuit. So if you're not in that region again for a while, you know, what are you going to do? The remote helps that now, remote hearings. But there was so much pushback against summary judgment by judges too, because they became huge. You get bankers boxes and an hour of help from lawyers. And so the pushback was not just the Court of Appeal, but even the trial judges as well.

And the lawyers saying, like everything else, it's just taking too long and costing too much money. So we see them still, but we're very circumspect about scheduling them. They better be ready to go before you're going to schedule them. And I think in some places, and maybe Toronto, you have to do a bit of a pretrial first now. Where they're talking about it, because why not? It is a final end to the case. You know, it's, it's never a problem. It's never been a problem for the specially endorsed writ kind of cases, for the liquidated damages, the mortgage remedy, or that kind of thing. But getting a big fact-laden case into summary judgment is very, very difficult today, I think.

Pulat Yunusov

In this context, okay, let's say summary judgment is dead as we used to know it, or it's very different now. What do you think about the next rule, Rule 21, determination of an issue before trial? What do you think its role is and what your experience has been with that rule?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, I absolutely agree with the Supreme Court of Canada and the— it was Imperial Oil, I think, Imperial Life, Imperial Tobacco, Imperial Tobacco maybe, where they talk about how important it is. It's a very important weed-out process, but it's not summary judgment. It's drafting. It's, has the plaintiff used the right words, usually. So the Court of Appeal has said in an appeal from me called Conway v. Law Society of Upper Canada, that you must give leave to amend unless it's impossible to plead. Well, so what I say to most lawyers is, you're bringing a Rule 21 motion, what you're doing is inviting the other side to amend and do a better job of it this time, after a judge tells them how.

So I'm— if you have a knockdown winner, somebody's just doing something that you can't do because either it's vexatious, or sometimes somebody's stretching the law and trying to stretch the law, I had one where somebody tried to take a run at Adler to the religious funding of, funding of religious schools, and I said, no, the Supreme Court of Canada has spoken. And so they had to appeal me to Div Court, and I don't know if they're going to try to get to the Court of Appeal to get somebody who can reopen the Supreme Court of Canada case if they can. But I struck that under Rule 21 because I was bound by Adler.

But so I think it's very useful, but in a very limited way, and I think it's overused I also think it could be done in writing. People sometimes will go on for hours. You read the pleading, it's got a cause of action or it doesn't. It's not— it's not a lot of magic to most of it. The only hard ones are Anns v. Merton, where, you know, are you creating a private law duty of care from a statute? Those get a little murkier. I think I'm in this week's ORs with one of those.

Pulat Yunusov

Gotta read that.

Justice Fred Myers

But there's something I want to talk about if you're going to get there. I come armed for you.

Pulat Yunusov

What is it? I

Justice Fred Myers

want to talk at some point. I'd like to be able to go on for a minute about the upfront model of the reform proposal that I think—

Pulat Yunusov

my next question.

Justice Fred Myers

Ah, perfect.

Pulat Yunusov

I was going to ask you about the Civil Rules Review.

Justice Fred Myers

Okay, well, I wasn't on the committee, but I was an adjunct.

Pulat Yunusov

Do you think that's fizzled out? Where, where is that? I mean, used to be a lot of hype about it. I don't hear about it anymore. What's going on there?

Justice Fred Myers

Ask the Attorney General.

Pulat Yunusov

Okay, okay.

Justice Fred Myers

But I'm the wrong guy. I have no insight into it. Honestly, I don't. There was a lot of talk.

Pulat Yunusov

There was a lot of talk. And let's talk about the upfront model, because I think it was a big part of the Civil Rules Review project or report.

Justice Fred Myers

And I don't think people quite understand why and what, what, what the impetus is and why we, we thought it was a good thing. But if you think about the current situation, And this is not a criticism of lawyers. People react, people organize their affairs by what they're entitled to do, what they're expected to do, and what the financial incentives are. That's fine. And as a result of the rules in 1984, when Chief Justice Morden said justice on the merits matters more than an adjournment. So if I can do justice, give the amendment. If I can do justice, give the adjournment. But adjourn, adjourn, adjourn, adjourn. Give the broadest of everything. So think about what you tell your juniors to draft a statement of claim.

Plead as broadly as you can. Plead every cause of action you can. Why? Because discovery comes from the pleading, and that way I can get every possible document on earth. And you go to discovery, ask every question you can ask, and try to get every document you can get, because what comes out after discovery 5 years into a case, you're arming your trial litigator with the broadest universe of documents and evidence, and your trial litigator then creates the theory of the case that he or she thinks has the best chance of winning at trial. And it may have nothing at all to do with what brought the clients into your office. In fact, it often doesn't.

There's often changes in personnel, you know. So we have created a system where every financial incentive is to back-end load the case, do everything as much as possible so that you do your theory of the case at the end. What if we say client comes in with a problem, you say, client, tell me about your problem. Here's what brings me to see you, I want to sue these guys. Okay, you've got an affidavit sitting in front of you, the client just told you his problem or her problem. And you've got the key documents. So you say, okay, here's a statement of claim, here's the key documents, here's the prima facie evidence. Other side respond, go to trial, stick a judge in the middle for a case management conference that can look at— do you need some discovery?

Do you need some documents? Do you need something else special? By the way, we do this already in the estates list. The Estates List has a motion for directions in every application where you set the issues, you set the discovery, you set all the procedural steps. So this isn't brand new, but— and the Estates List actually requires an upfront prima facie case in, in evidence. So the idea is if you can get to trial quickly on the issue that brought the clients in on their actual lis Maybe we could have quicker, cheaper trials. It's not going to be as lucrative. Businesses— the business model is going to change. Hopefully it'll increase volume. I'll tell you one thing it'll do: it'll eliminate the need to settle 99% of cases.

Hopefully we'll be able to get to trial with a bunch. And if you eliminate refusals motions, you free up one-third of Associate Justice's time. Can you believe that? 1/3 of their time is long refusals motions when most trials have no discovery refusals read in. And in Nortel, the biggest trial ever with 100,000 refusals, not a single one was read in. So the upfront model is designed to react against the delay, delay, cost, cost of the current back-end loaded model, and nobody says it. Like, it's not written anywhere that the theory of the case must be decided at the end. Tell me, do you know that the results of our decision, of our cases, are that much more just than other systems that have quicker, cheaper processes?

I can tell you 80% of cases, an experienced civil litigator can tell from the pleadings what's likely to happen. Likely, not always, but a lot. You know, there's no empirical data that asking every last question does anything to increase the justness of the result, but we do know from Hryniak that the delay undermines the justice, and that's what the old rules didn't contemplate. So speeding up cases by front-end loading, requiring the theory of the case to be day one, go and run it through a judge and set the parameters to get to trial with fair procedure through that process. It doesn't mean no discovery ever. It doesn't mean no documents ever, but you're going to go to a judge and work it out and work it out with your colleague and get to trial quickly.

That's the best of all possible worlds. Now, you know how they're going to draft it and what it's going to look like. And, you know, some cases we know, we know some cases need more. You're not taking a car accident to trial. Unless you have hundreds of pages of medical evidence. We know that there's going to have to be, and there are in the current draft, there's streams for different kinds of cases. You're always going to have the massive commercial case that's going to have to be dealt with on the commercial list separately. Those are case managed already too. I think people were worried and jumped to conclusions about what this upfront model meant when in fact it's aiming at the very part of the problem in our system, which is delay and the back-end incentives, the incentives to delay and expand.

Pulat Yunusov

This is where— well, as usual, home run. But being me, I have to cross-examine you a little bit, if you don't mind. So do you think we are obsessed a little bit with trials? And do you think it's a vestige of the old generations? And again, I apologize that I have been attacking the old generation in this interview, but the things are changing so fast now. So we have to reexamine every assumption or, you know, bad things, figuratively speaking, can happen. So are we obsessed with trials? You mentioned earlier that judges didn't like summary judgment motions because they had to read boxes of material and then have only only 1 hour of help from lawyers.

And the key word here is help. So what is the adversarial justice system? It's lawyers meeting with judges together and lawyers helping judges understand the law and the facts. Of course, from the point of view of their clients, judges need lawyers. Without lawyers, judges are helpless. And in fact, they're not allowed to make decisions without— I mean, Necessarily lawyers are required, but they strongly preferred. At least parties are required, at least, right? I mean, this is, this is the fundamental rule. So now if you are advocating for a front-loaded system because it will result in more trials, what if the technological change will make this help from lawyers obsolete? What if judges will not need it as much?

Right? What if they— what if judges will be able to do in 15 minutes by themselves what they needed 5 hours with 2 highly educated lawyers charging $700 an hour to do?

Justice Fred Myers

We've been advocating, some of us, and I think Civil Justice said some of this, the short motions. I said 5 years ago, short motions should be in writing. You know, short motions, most of them, most associate justice motions, for example, don't need much of an appearance. And if you're in American circuit courts, you're lucky if the judge calls you in and asks you a question or two for a minute or two. So I'm not troubled by that. But trials have two problems. One is there's a narrative to be told, and Some of us are oral learners. I think we all like being told the story. It's a different way of learning. It's a different way of approaching a case as a narrative unfolds in front of you.

It, it might give you a deeper understanding. I'm not positive, but it might. But here's the bigger problem: human beings aren't accurate recorders and repeaters of facts. So every case, you get two versions or more of facts. And we have to decide which version is the most likely. And that's— so it's not the judge's mind reading the boxes, it's at the end of the read, you don't know who to believe. And some have said that cross-examination is the best baloney detector that we have. Substitute another word that starts with B for baloney. We don't have, you know, we don't We don't even know if truth, what do you call it, lie detector machines work.

But even if they do, we know that people can honestly remember events differently. Your brain spins them differently. So it's the best we have. And I don't, the computer, until the AI is able to replicate human judgment, in looking at people and listening to people and trying then to determine whose version of the truth is the more likely we're still going to need trials. Trials are going to be the way to do it. And AI— I mean, I know we're not going into AI now, but the issues of, you know, of course, if you give it enough— if you give it enough precedence— somebody said they could never have human judgment. Well, of course they can.

If they have enough precedence, they'll see when judges exercise kindness and mercy and judgment. But there are those who say, you know, remember, you're learning off of historic data, and if historic data is inherently biased, both by our society and the societal norms that were in play at the time, but also just in what's reported and what's not. So, you know, we're a ways away from replacing the trial. I don't know any way yet that is better at getting to the best, the best truth we can and giving the parties the feeling of being heard, which is part of the justice of their case. You know, the whole legitimacy of our system is independent judges sworn to be fair and unbiased and impartial, and they're telling their case.

And I can't tell you the number of times I've had people in chambers Adults tell me their stories, start to cry, and when I've been a bit empathetic to their— and heard their concerns, they go off and settle. They want to be heard by a person in authority. And there's a catharsis to trials that I think is part of the justice of them. I love trials. I'm a big fan of trials. And I think it's a shame that under our current system, you must settle 98% because we don't have the resources to hear the rest.

Pulat Yunusov

Well, you know, I appreciate your words. They're very important. I would love to speak more about trials. It's also one of my favorite topics, but we have to go on to AI now. It's just too big to be skipped. And you played your role in the relationship between AI and the legal profession. You know, I, I'm just going to start by asking you— it's an open-ended question— say whatever you want about AI, what you think about it, and then I'm going to ask you about a couple specific things.

Justice Fred Myers

Well, what I think about it is it doesn't matter what I think about it. It's here to stay. It's been adopted by all segments of society unquestioningly for better in some cases and despite warts in others. And I don't think we know enough yet about what its best uses are. I'm going to talk to you at some point about legal research and AI, which I've got a conference coming out with the Law Society in January that's going to be all about how to teach AI for legal research in particular, because it's got some very specific problems associated with it. Hallucinations are the low-hanging fruit. They are the headline maker, but actually they're easy.

They shouldn't happen. The harder issues is what to do about evidence, validity, and authenticity. That's now suddenly an issue. And slop. Slop is a big problem. AI increases access to justice. We have so many people telling us how great it is that now self-reps aren't writing nonsense, they're writing with AI. And it is true, it is superficially better. It but when you've read 20 pages and realized it hasn't said a thing in those 20 pages, it's a problem. And think of the small claims court judge who now every single case is full of AI hallucinations and warts and slop too. It's it's got its own institutional issues

Pulat Yunusov

and forged evidence, probably.

Justice Fred Myers

Well, there's deliberate deepfakes, but there's also unacknowledged AI. You know, what about the accountant who gets on a witness stand and says, here's my cash flow forecast. Did you use your computer to prepare that? Yes. Does your firm use AI? Yes. What did the AI do? I don't

Pulat Yunusov

know.

Justice Fred Myers

Did you run it twice and see if you got the same answer twice? No. You know, how do we know? And let's assume that it's— that all AI is beneficent. You still don't know what it's doing or why or whether it's valid and replicable. But why should we assume that it's all beneficent and that there's no maliciousness built in? Why wouldn't companies build into their AI things to prefer itself?

Pulat Yunusov

Very interesting point. Very interesting point. You gave an interview to Law Times this year and you talked about automatic detection of hallucinated citations in court filings.

Justice Fred Myers

Wouldn't that be great?

Pulat Yunusov

That'd be great. And I agree with you that it's not even that hard. And I agree with you that it's a low-hanging fruit, the hallucinated citations and hallucinations in general. I mean, we have a standard electronic repository of case law in this country. It's called CanLII. So what do you think about the role of CanLII in the AI revolution and in connection with your proposal, for example?

Justice Fred Myers

Well, they've got their own AI, which I understand is really just a citation, not a citation, a Sorry, a search builder. You ask it a question, it translates it into a Boolean search. I think CanLII, we're very lucky to have CanLII. CanLII isn't 100% universal though, so there's still cases out there that you have to get off of Quicklaw and elsewhere. So it's not perfect, but by far the vast, vast, vast majority of what we see in factums and in court is references to CanLII, which is wonderful.

Pulat Yunusov

CanLII is really the standard citation database today. I mean, you are required to use CanLII links in factums now in some jurisdictions, at least in Ontario. But

Justice Fred Myers

CanLII, they're getting scraped, right? They're getting scraped and they don't like it. And I don't know anywhere near enough about it, but there's— I know there's at least one website out there that has every single case.

Pulat Yunusov

AI necessarily, by implication, implies bot access. And they're blocking it. Do you think they will have to open it to bots at some point to enable lawyers to fully access the case law through this new generation of tools?

Justice Fred Myers

I think there's a fine question to not ask me, but there's there are certainly copyright cases going on, right? And so the degree to which someone can use somebody else's database will be determined in the fullness of time. Sorry.

Pulat Yunusov

Understood. Now, you had— you decided some cases about AI. Do you think such cases will come before the courts again? They were really about hallucinations. Do you think we're done with hallucinated citations or hallucinated submissions?

Justice Fred Myers

Sadly, no. Sadly, no. In fact, the American experience, even with their judges' ability to sanction lawyers and the running rate in the United States now is settled around 5 $25,000 per hallucination from the lawyers personally, and that has not cut the numbers. In fact, the number of hallucination cases apparently is still going up. So the greed and lack of understanding is, is more durable than punishment. So now you'll also notice that I'm the only case that's reported that had a contempt citation. Now, my facts were particularly difficult. I've referred another case to the Law Society and heard nothing further in the year since. And I don't know that many judges have done that.

There's been sort of a certain degree, I think, of acceptance of, you know, just say no, no, and ignore it and push through because it doesn't really hurt anything. But then as soon as you see a judge's decision with something cited in it, and what's happening now in the States apparently is some of the cases, it's It's not that you cite an AI case, it's you cite a case that's got AI in it, and that case cites another case that was a hallucination. So sometimes you could be citing a case and there's 4 generations of AI citations within it, because each one cited another one. So it gets, you know, it's going to pollute the bloodline of the common law if they get into decisions.

Pulat Yunusov

Well, I'm not going to belabor the point that if our case law repositories were more open to automated verification, which you suggested for filings, then we would have fewer hallucinated citations. Because, I mean, the repository of case law is right there. Compare your citation with that authentic authoritative repository and you're done. The problem solved. But

Justice Fred Myers

maybe, maybe in the future, who signs the factum do what he or she is signing for.

Pulat Yunusov

Exactly. Yes, yes, yes, yes. But you know, I mean, the system where people who sign factums delegate the actual work to others is not new. It's just that others are different.

Justice Fred Myers

I read every case, or at least I looked at every case. You know, if I knew what the case was and I knew what it was about, and I might look at the paragraph that I might need in court. But before I sent the factum in, I've looked at every case. Okay, makes sense.

Pulat Yunusov

I want to close. I mean, our hour is almost up. I want to close. Yeah, I mean, time flies when I speak with you. I mean, I wish I could speak for another 5 hours, but no, time is scarce, just like mentorship spots. Can you talk about your vision for this tenure on the Court of Appeal? You mentioned how many years you think you have left. I mean, you, you don't necessarily have that many years left because, I don't know, is there mandatory retirement on the Court of Appeal? I mean, you can stay longer. Oh,

Justice Fred Myers

there is mandatory.

Pulat Yunusov

Okay, 75. So you have that many years. What is your vision? What do you hope to accomplish in the remaining time?

Justice Fred Myers

Well I was able I would have been able to go supernumerary in January of '29. I've had to promise the Chief Justice, and I have promised, that I won't go for 5 years. So I've got at least 5 years. So it's until 72, early 72, or age 75. I really hope to spend the first bit, taking in from my colleagues the institutional norms and practices, how they approach making some of the big decisions that we get called upon to make. The freight I can move, and I'm not, I'm not too worried with freight. There's, there's language, there's norms about how to dismiss a case and how to make sure you cite the standard of review appropriately, and my time on the divisional court will stand me in good stead as I learn how it's done here.

So I hope to be part of the development of the common law in a way that I think is sensible and meets the needs, the best needs of the public. I hope to maintain my independence. I don't mean judicial independence. I mean my personal independence as not just institutional, but my Fred voice. Like it or leave it, that it's me. And I have, if there's one general theory that I don't mind exposing, it's I'm not a big fan of the words holistic and contextual approach. If absolutely everything in law is a holistic contextual approach to all the facts and all the factors. It means you're making an equitable decision in every single case, and there's no certainty.

And I think nothing settles cases better and resolves disputes better than certainty of the law. And so that's sort of a— I'm not on a crusade of any kind, but that's sort of an approach that has dawned on me that I'm pretty secure in.

Pulat Yunusov

Well, my friends, this has been Justice Fred Myers of the Ontario Court of Appeal. Thank you for your Fred voice, Justice Myers. We really appreciate it. Thank you so much.

Justice Fred Myers

My colleagues say that when, when I get a nasty decision, they call it a Freddygram.

Pulat Yunusov

That's a good one. Thank you.

Justice Fred Myers

Thank you, Pulat.